…against HB 516? Hearing starts Monday at 3pm in Room 405 of the Montana State Capitol Building.

I suggest printing two copies of your statement and bring it with you in case the monkey business of last time is repeated.

Here’s mine:

Regarding HB 516, I speak in opposition for several reasons.

  • Every community should have the right to decide its own ordinances of inclusion. Ordinances of exclusion, which is what this is, are historically used by dictatorships, theocratic states and societies of intolerance- which I fervently hope is not your intention.
  • Creating a law that disallows protection is counterintuitive to the purpose of government as set forth in both the Federal and State Constitutions, in which are stated explicitly the government’s purpose and responsibility to protect its citizenry from discrimination, violence and other harms.
  • This is an attempt to write prejudice and bigotry into the law. It is an attempt to tie local ordinances to State law in a way which keeps government from evolving as our understanding does- both scientific and social, creating a top-down model, instead of a cooperative, inter-dynamic process. State laws and statutes are informed by the experience of the people- don’t disregard the deliberate and intentional process engaged in by sizable numbers of Montanans- processes which inform the future of our government.
  • I am a gay man, a native Montanan. My partner is a native Montanan. All we want is to live our lives happily and free from fear in the state we both grew up in. This bill tells me we shouldn’t have the right to be happy here.

  • I am also a therapist, I work primarily with LGBT persons. The stories of fear and prejudice that I hear almost daily are heart-breaking. The stories of bullying and violence are also all too common and very real right here in the State of Montana. This bill simply ignores the needs of a suffering segment of the population who deserve to feel safe.
  • This bill is discrimination. It is rejection of the right of communities to protect their citizens as they believe necessary. It removes the power to govern from local citizens, enshrining bigotry, ignorance and personal belief in defiance of science, human experience and the freedom of local governance.

Respectfully submitted,
D Gregory Smith, MA, stl

2 comments on “Hey!

  1. gg says:

    Is MT going the way of Wisconsin & Michigan? The GOP has no integrity, let alone charity & rights for the masses.
    Sounds like the Westboro Baptist Church has a branch in Big Sky Country
    Hopefully Montanans know more about US history than does Michele Bachmann, the twit from MN.
    She recently told an audience in Concord, New Hampshire that they should be proud to be the home of the American Revolution Patriots. Alas, that site is in Massachusestts, down the road a bit. ( http://politifi.com/news/Bachmann-Screws-Up-Fifth-Grade-American-History-1743592.html)

    Just goes to show that satan takes on many guises, lately his name is GOP.



  2. […] Gregory Smith says it much better (and more directly) than I did. Read what he had to say. Share 2011 Legislature, MT Politics, Montana Legislature bigotry, Dallas Erickson, […]


Comments are closed.